Draft Assessment Report On Paeonia Lactiflora Pallas, Radix (Paeoniae Radix Alba)
o
EUROPEAN MEDICINES AGENCY
SCIENCE MEDICINES HEALTH
02 February 2016
EMA/HHMP/762954/2015
Committee on Herbal Medicinal Products (HMPC)
Assessment report on Paeonia lactiflora Pallas, radix (Paeoniae radix alba)
Draft
Based on Article 10a of Directive 2001/83/EC as amended (well-established use)
Based on Article 16d(1), Article 16f and Article 16h of Directive 2001/83/EC as amended (traditional use)
|
Herbal substance(s) (binomial scientific name of |
Paeonia lactiflora Pallas, radix |
|
the plant, including plant part) |
(Paeoniae radix alba) |
|
Herbal preparation(s) |
Not applicable |
|
Pharmaceutical form(s) |
Not applicable |
|
Rapporteur(s) |
W. Knöss |
|
Peer-reviewer |
H. Pinto Ferreira |
Note: This draft assessment report is published to support the public consultation of the draft public statement on Paeoniae radix alba. It is a working document, not yet edited, and shall be further developed after the release for consultation of the public statement. Interested parties are welcome to submit comments to the HMPC secretariat, which will be taken into consideration but no 'overview of comments received during the public consultation' will be prepared on comments that will be received on this assessment report. The publication of this draft assessment report has been agreed to facilitate the understanding by Interested Parties of the assessment that has been carried out so far and led to the preparation of the draft public statement.
An agency of the European Union
30 Churchill Place • Canary Wharf • London E14 5EU • United Kingdom Telephone +44 (0)20 3660 6000 Facsimile +44 (0)20 3660 5555 Send a question via our website www.ema.europa.eu/contact
© European Medicines Agency, 2016. Reproduction is authorised provided the source is acknowledged.
Table of contents...................................................................................................................2
1.1. Description of the herbal substance(s), herbal preparation(s) or combinations thereof ..4
2.1.1. Information about products on the market in the EU/EEA Member States.................6
2.1.2. Information on products on the market outside the EU/EEA....................................6
2.2. Information on documented medicinal use and historical data from literature..............7
3.1. Overview of available pharmacological data regarding the herbal substance(s), herbal
3.2. Overview of available pharmacokinetic data regarding the herbal substance(s), herbal
3.3. Overview of available toxicological data regarding the herbal substance(s)/herbal
4.1.1. Overview of pharmacodynamic data regarding the herbal substance(s)/preparation(s)
4.1.2. Overview of pharmacokinetic data regarding the herbal substance(s)/preparation(s)
5.5.7. Effects on ability to drive or operate machinery or impairment of mental ability......41
1. Introduction
1.1. Description of the herbal substance(s), herbal preparation(s) or combinations thereof
• Herbal substance(s)
Paeonia lactiflora Pallas, radix is not yet covered by the current European Pharmacopoeia 8th edition (2015). A draft monograph of the EUROPEAN PHARMACOPOEIA COMMISSION Pharmeuropa 27.1 defines the herbal substance.
Pharmeuropa 27.1 (draft)
"PEONY ROOT, WHITE; Paeoniae radix alba; Baishao;S^ is the whole or fragmented, peeled, boiled and dried root of Paeonia lactiflora Pallas with rhizome and rootlets removed. Content: minimum 1.6 per cent of paeoniflorin (C23H28O11; Mr 480.5) (dried herbal substance)". The absence of Paeonol is part of the identification.
The herbal substance is described in further pharmacopoeias:
British Pharmacopoeia (2014) Volume IV
White Peony Root is the dried whole root of Paeonia lactiflora Pallas (Paeonia albiflora Pallas; Paeonia edulis Salisb.; Paeonia officinalis Thunb.). It contains not less than 1.6% of paeoniflorin (C23H28O11), calculated with reference to the dried material.
Processed White Peony Root has been boiled, peeled and dried. It contains not less than 1.6% of paeoniflorin (C23H28O11), calculated with reference to the dried material.
Pharmacopoeia of the People's Republic of China (2010)
White Peony Root is the dried root of Paeonia lactiflora Pallas. The herbal substance is collected in summer or autumn, washed clean, removed from two ends and rootlet, either peeled after boiling in water or boiled after peeling, and dried.
The pharmacopoeia of Japan XVI (2011)
Peony Root is the root of Paeonia lactiflora Pallas (Paeonaceae).
WHO Monographs on Selected Medicinal Plants 1999
Radix Paeoniae is the dried root of Paeonia lactiflora Pallas (Paeonaceae) with reference to the Pharmacopoeia of Japan and the Pharmacopoeia of the People's republic of China.
Main characteristic constituents of the herbal substance
According to Blaschek et al. (2013) the herbal substance contains monoterpenes and monoterpenes glycosides (as paeoniflorin, albiflorin, oxipaeoniflorin), gallotannines, triterpenoids as 8-sitosterol, daucosterol, benzoic acid, carbohydrates.
There is a great variation in the content of constituents depending on the harvest period and usage of peeled or unpeeled herbal substance.
Paeonols are mainly found in the root bark of P. suffruticosa, which is not part of this herbal substance.
Synonyms
Radix Paeoniae iactifiorae alba, English: Peony, Peony root; German: Weiße Pfingstrosen Wurzeln; Chinese: Baishao; Japans: Paishao.
Potential confounding materials
Paeonia iactifiora var. trichocarpa Stern; Paeonia japonica (Makino) Miyabe & H. Takeda; Paeonia suffruticosa Andrews syn; Paeonia moutan Sims (Herbal Medicines Compendium, 2013).
The Pharmeuropa 27.1 contains a test of thin-layer chromatography for identification of the herb and specification of the absence of paeonol.
White peony is distinguished from red peony by the process of peeling, cooking in water and drying of the root of Paeonia iactifiora. (Bruneton, 1995).
• Herbal preparation(s)
Herbal preparations described in the pharmacopoeias:
Comminuted herbal substance (Pharmeanalyseduropa 27.1)
Powdered Peony Root (JP XVI 2011)
Assessors 'comment
Potential confounding is possible as a lot of different definitions of "peony radix" exist in parallel and the published non clinical and clinical literature does not always gives exact information. For example the pharmacopoeia of Japan XVI (2011) and the WHO does not distinguish red and white peony.
In conclusion, in cases where publications refer to "white" ore "red"peony they are only cited in the according monograph. In cases where the publications refers to "Paeonia lactiflora" or "peony root" in general, the literature is considered in both monographs.
• Combinations of herbal substance(s) and/or herbal preparation(s) including a description of vitamin(s) and/or mineral(s) as ingredients of traditional combination herbal medicinal products assessed, where applicable.
1.2. Search and assessment methodology
A literature search was performed using the DIMDI (Deutsches Institut für Medizinische Dokumentation und Information)-database information system (in ZT00; CC00; CCTR93; CDSR93; DAHTA; CDAR94; AR96; GA03; GM03; INAHTA; MK77; NHSEED; ED93; ME60; CV72; CB85; AZ72; IA70; BA70; EM47; DH64; EA08; DD83; II78; IS74), the database of the division for Complementary and Alternative Medicines of the Federal Institute for Drugs and Medical Devices (BfArM) and information received from other member states or submitted as response to the call for scientific data by EMA. Additional hand searches were performed in books on herbal medicines and plant monographs in the BfArM own library. The bibliographies of included trials and other relevant reviews were searched to identify further potential trials.
2. Data on medicinal use
2.1. Information about products on the market
2.1.1. Information about products on the market in the EU/EEA Member States
Information on medicinal products marketed in the EU/EEA
According to the information provided by the National Competent Authorities in the EU (Belgium, Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Italy, Lativia, Lichtenstein, Lithuania, Luxemburg, Malta, The Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Slovak Republic, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden and United Kingdom) no authorised or registered medicinal products are on the market.
Information on relevant combination medicinal products marketed in the EU/EEA
Not applicable.
Information on other products marketed in the EU/EEA (where relevant)
2.1.2. Information on products on the market outside the EU/EEA
White peony root is traditionally used in TCM in combination with other herbal substances. Information on products marketed in China is not available.
Klein et al. (2010) analysed prescription patterns of Chinese Medicinal Herbs in Switzerland from the database of Lian Chinaherb AG. Bai shao (Paeoniae radix alba) was one of the most commonly used herbs and was used in 41.4% of the TCM-prescriptions. Paeoniae radix rubra was used less frequently.
The table 2 shows, the whole ore fragmented, dried root of Paeonia lactiflora (Paeoniae radix rubra) has a different use in the TCM compared with peeled, boiled and dry root (Paeoniae radix alba).
Table 2: Comparison of the TCM-use of white and red peony root
|
Pharmacopoeia of the People's Republic of China (2010): indication for peony root, white |
Pharmacopoeia of the People's Republic of China (2010): indication for peony root, red |
|
Indications (TCM) • Blood deficiency and sallow complexion • Menstrual irregularities • Spontaneous sweating • Night sweating • Hypochondriac pain • Abdominal pain • Spasm and pain of limbs • Headache and dizziness |
Indications (TCM) • Heat entering nutrient-blood aspects • Macula and papula caused by warm toxin • Hematemesis and epistaxis • Red painful swelling eyes • Liver depression with hypochondriac pain • Amenorrhea and dysmenorrhea • Abdominal pain caused by aggregation and accumulation • Injuries from falls • Swelling abscess • Sore and ulcer |
Feng et al. (2010) and Zhang (2013) reported, Paeoniae radix rubra and Paeoniae radix alba are both TCMs commonly used in China. Although being of similar origins, the clinical efficacies of the two medicines are regarded different. The two TCMs are regarded as two independent medicines.
2.2. Information on documented medicinal use and historical data from literature
White peony root is used in Chinese herbal medicines. As it is presented in table 2, European pharmacopoeias or accepted collections in the European Union Member States have not introduced white peony root. Thus, there are no data available on posology or indications for medicinal use within the European Union.
Table 2: Overview of historical data
|
Herbal preparation |
Documented use / Traditional use |
Pharmaceutical form |
Reference |
|
Comminuted herbal substance |
Action (TCM): To nourish blood and regulate menstruation Astringe yin to check sweating Emolliate the liver and relieve pain Pacify and repress the liver yang Indication (TCM): Blood deficiency and sallow complexion Menstrual irregularities Spontaneous sweating Night sweating Hypochondriac pain Abdominal pain Spasm and pain of limbs Headache and dizziness |
Daily dose: 6-15 g (TCM: decoct) |
Pharmacopoeia of the People's Republic of China (2010) |
|
Comminuted herbal substance Dried root of Paeonia lactiflora P. but not Paeonia veitchii Lynch. |
Uses supported by clinical data: None Uses described in pharmacopoeias and in traditional systems of medicine: As analgesic, anti-inflammatory and antispasmodic in the treatment of Amenorrhoea Dysmenorrhoea Pain in the chest and abdomen Dementia Headache Vertigo Spasm of the calf muscles Liver disease Allergies Anticoagulant |
Daily dose: 6-15 g crude plant material, powder, decoction |
WHO monographs (1999) |
|
Comminuted herbal substance |
The use according ChinP IX is not recommended as the efficacy is not proved |
Blaschek et all HagerROM 2013 | |
|
Comminuted herbal substance and preparations thereof |
Negative-monograph for paeonia radix (public statement) |
Kommission E (1988) | |
|
P. officinalis L. Radix paeoniae |
Antispasmodicum, Use in folk medicine for asthma, cramps and gout |
No information |
Hoppe (1981) |
|
P. officinalis L. Radix paeoniae |
Antispasmodicum, cramps of the stomach, antiepilepticum |
tincture of wine (1:5): Single dose: 5-10 drops |
Madaus(1976) |
2.3. Overall conclusions on medicinal use
There is no herbal preparation for which 15 years of medicinal use in the EU could be confirmed from the literature or based on the regulatory status overview in EU. The requirement laid down in Article 16a(1)(d) of Directive 2001/83/EC that "the period of traditional use as laid down on Article 16c(1)(c) has elapsed", is not fulfilled.
3. Non-Clinical Data
3.1. Overview of available pharmacological data regarding the herbal substance(s), herbal preparation(s) and relevant constituents thereof
3.1.1. Primary pharmacodynamics
Antispasmodic activity In-vitro
Paeoniflorigenone
Kimura et al. (1984) found blocking effects of paeoniflorigenone, isolated from cold aqueous extracts of peony root, on neuromuscular junctions of frogs and mice. The suppressing effect by paeoniflorigenone (300 pg/ml) was not reversed by neostigmine. Paeoniflorigenone (100 pg/ml) inhibited weakly acetylcholine (5 pg/ml) induced slow contractions. Paeoniflorigenone decompressed on heating, therefore, the authors concluded that it may not necessarily play a predominant role in the clinical therapy of muscle pain.
Assessor's comments
For in-vitro data, a physiological correlation is not possible. The tested substance paeoniflorigenone is only a component of the root. The results do not highlight any specific activity for the aqueous extract of the whole root.
Anti-inflammatory activity and arthritis activity In-vitro
Total glycosides of Paeonia lactiflora Pall root (TGP)
(ethanol reflux, ethylacetat extraction, dried powder, consists of 90% paeoniflorin)
Chang et al. (2009) showed that TGP (312.5 pg/ml) significantly inhibited the proliferation of synoviocytes, decreased the production of IL-1, TNF-a, PGE2, and elevated the level of cAMP. The authors concluded the results indicated that TGP might exert its anti-inflammatory effects through inhibiting the production of pro-inflammatory mediators in synoviocytes of CIA rats, which might be associated with its ability to regulate cAMP-dependent EP2/EP4-mediated pathway.
Paeoniflorin
Chen JY et al. (2012) showed that paeoniflorin inhibited proliferation of fibroblast-like synoviocytes through suppressing g-protein-coupled receptor kinase 2. As compared with the normal rats, the expression or g-protein-coupled receptor kinase 2 increased significantly in fibroblast-like synoviocytes from CIA rats. After treatment with paeoniflorin (105 -8 mol/l) the expression of g-protein-coupled receptor kinase 2 in fibroblast-like synoviocytes (in-vitro) decreased evidently.
Jiang B et al. (2012) examined the inhibitory effect of paeoniflorin on the inflammatory vicious cycle between adipocytes and macrophages. The authors concluded, paeoniflorin exhibits anti-inflammatory properties by inhibiting the vicious cycle between 3T3-Li-adipocytes and RAW 264.7-macrophages.
In-vivo
Paeoniflorin
Li et al, (2012) treated collagen-induced arthritis rats with Paeoniflorin (25, 100 mg/kg) intragastrically from day 18 to 38 after immunization. In CIA rats the levels of anti-CII antibody, IgA, IgG and IgM in serum enhanced, BAFF/BAFF-R, PI3K, p-Akt and m-TOR were highly expressed. Paeoniflorin (100 mg/kg) decreased arthritis score, relieved ankle and paw swelling, improved spleen histopathology and decreased the levels of IgA, IgM, IgG and anti-CII antibody.
Wu et al. (2014) determinates paeoniflorin in rat plasma, following the oral administration of Paeoniae radix alba aqueous decoction, showing to be absorbed. In the pharmacological experiment paeoniflorin was administered for four weeks in a low, middle and high dose (0.5; 1 and 3 mg/kg/day) in rats with collagen-induced arthritis. Paeoniflorin significantly improved the disease resistant ability of RA rats and reduced the levels of the inflammatory cytokines IL-18 and TNF-a.
Zheng YQ et al. (2007) studied the effects and mechanisms of paeoniflorin, a bioactive glucoside from peony root, on adjuvant arthritis in rats. Rats were treated with paeoniflorin (5, 10, 20 mg/kg) orally from day 14 to 20 after inducing adjuvant artritis. Paeoniflorin an 10, 20 mg/kg /day suppressed rat AA at least partly by inhibiting abnormal proliferation of synoviocytes and the production of IL-1, PGE2, IL-6, VEGF and GM-CSF by synoviocytes and reducing Cox-2 expression.
Total glucosides of peony
Zheng YQ and Wei (2005) found that total glucosides of peony suppressed adjuvant arthritis in rats and intervenes cytokine-signalling between different types of synoviocytes. Intragastric administration of TGP (25, 50, 100 mg/kg bw, days 14-21) significantly decreased secondary inflammatory reaction, bone destruction and ultrastructure change of synoviocytes in in adjuvant arthritis rats The results suggested, TGP possesses anti-inflammatory effects by modulating the pro-inflammatory mediators production from MLS and phosphorylation of macrophage like synoviocytes (MAPKs) from fibroblast-like-synoviocytes (FLS).
Zhu L et al. (2005) analysed the effect and mechanisms of total glucosides of peony on joint damage in rat collagen-induced arthritis. TGP (25, 50, 100 mg/kg/d) was orally administered to rats from day 14 to 28 after immunisation. The therapeutic effect of TGP could be associated with its ability to ameliorate the secretion and metabolism of synoviocytes and to inhibit the abnormal proliferation and VEGF, bFGF, MMP-1 and MMP-3 production by FLS.
Zhu L, Wei W, Zheng YQ (2006) found that TGP has inhibitory effect on hyper functional synoviocytes from rats with collagen-induced arthritis. The authors suggested, its mechanism may be related with the inhibition of abnormal proliferation and secretion of synoviocytes.
Xu HM et al. (2007) analys in-vitroed the effects and mechanisms of total glucosides of peony on adjuvant arthritis in rats. Intragastric administration of TGP (50, 100 mg/kg bw) significantly decreased secondary inflammatory reaction in adjuvant arthritis rats. Suppressing the activity of IL-1 and TNFa, decreased PGE2 and increased cAMP levels in synoviocytes of AA rats were observed after TGP administration. In the immunoblot analysis TGP could up-regulate the expression EP2 and EP4.
Lin J et al. (2012) found that total glucosides of peony inhibits Th1/Th17 cells via decreasing dendritic cells activation in rheumatoid arthritis. TGP treatment (150 mg/kg i.p.) significantly decreased percentage and number of Th1 and Th17 cells in collagen induced arthritis (CIA) in mice. TGP treatment inhibited dendritic cells (DCs) maturation and reduced production of IL-12 and IL-6. Moreover, TGP treatment in RA patients showed shank population of matured DCs and IFN-y-, IL-17-production cells.
Wei et al. (2013) administered orally TGP at 60 mg/kg bw for 3 month to New Zeeland rabbits with antigen-induced arthritis. The authors concluded, that total glucosides of peonyprevent juxta-articular bone loss and prevent subchondral bone destruction in experimental arthritis.
In-vivo
"Baishao" extract/White peony root extract
Jiang et al. (2011) examined the influence of Paeonia lactiflora roots extract on cAMP-phosphodiesterase activity and related anti-inflammatory action. Baishao extract was prepared according to the methods of traditional aqueous extraction and ethanol sediment. Finally the extract was filtered and lyophilized and the average yield was 11.7% (w/w). The extract had significant inhibition on cAMP-phosphodiesterase activity, had dose dependent restrain on neutrophils respiratory burst, inhibition at low concentration and promotion at high concentration on elastase release. At 10 mg crude herb/g body weight (intraperitoneal), swelling was inhibited by 58.2%, 50.48% and 35.67% at 3h, 6h, 15 h respectively in the rat arthritis model.
Assessor's comments
The tested substance paeoniflorin is only a component of the root. The results do not highlight any specific activity for the aqueous extract of the whole root. For in-vitro data with paeoniflorin a physiological correlation is not possible. The in-vivo data with orally administered TGP hint to antiinflammatory activity. The tested dose is unclear, as no information on the DER of the extracts is given and the extraction solvent is not described clearly. The used alcoholic extract (TGP) is not part of the preparations discussed in this AR. One in-vivo study (Jiang et al., 2011) refers to the whole plant extract but was administered intraperitonealy, so physiological conclusions are limited.
Analgesic activity
In-vivo
Paeoniflorin
The results of the study Lee KK et al. (2011) showed peony radix and gentiana radix extracts orally administered, did not induce significant anti-nociception in non-diabetic mice. However peony radix (250, 500 mg/kg, no DER information) dose-dependently increased the nociceptive threshold in diabetic mice between 0.5 and 2 h after administration. Both paeoniflorin (30 mg/kg) and albiflorin (10 mg/kg) significantly elevated the nociceptive threshold between 0.5 and 3 h and between 0.5 and 1 h after oral administration, respectively.
Zhang WJ et al. (2009) found that the analgesic effect of paeoniflorin in rats with neonatal maternal separation-induced visceral hyperalgesia is mediated through adenosine A(1) receptor by inhibiting the extracellular signal-regulated protein kinase (ERK) pathway. Paeoniflorin was administered by i.p. injection (180 mg/kg bw) and morphine (5 mg/kg bw) was chosen as positive control.
Assessor's comments
The results for peony radix extract (no further information) are contradictory regarding antinociception. The tested substance paeoniflorin is only a component of the root so, the results are limited for conclusions on clinical relevance.
Aqueous extract
Rawat and Malviya (2010) tested the antipyretic activity of aqueous root extract of Paeoniae radix (100 and 200 mg/kg orally, the percentage yield of the prepared extract was 12%±0.51 (w/w)) in rats. The root extract showed significant reduction in normal body temperature and yeast-provoked elevated temperature comparable to that of paracetamol. The antipyretic effect was started at 1 h and extended for at least 4 h after administration.
Assessor's comments
The tested extract concentrations 100 and 200 mg/kg orally correspond to approximately 7-14 g extract/ 58-116 g herbal substance in a 70 kg person. The tested concentrations are higher as the used human doses in TCM, so the clinical relevance is unclear.
Androgen modulating activity and phytoestrogenic-like effects
In-vivo
Hao et al. (2009) studied phytoestrogenic-like effects of four kinds of Chinese medicine including Paeoniae radix alba (no information on herbal substance/extract) in female SD rats. The rats were treated 4 days. Paeoniae radix alba could increase the immature rat's uterus wet weight and the ratio of uterus to body weight (p<0.05). The serum stimulated proliferation of MCF7 cell respectively compared with normal control. The serum could increase the expression of ERa (p<0.05).
Assessor's comments
The results hint to a phyto-estrogenic effect of the herbal substance, but are of limited relevance, as the tested dose is unclear, as no information on the DER of the extracts is given and the extraction solvent is not described clearly.
Anti-allergic-activity
In-vivo
Ethanolic extract, Paeonol, Paeoniflorin
Lee B (2008) analysed the anti-allergic effect of the root of Paeonia lactiflora (80% ethanolic extract) and its constituents paeoniflorin and paeonol in the model of passive cutaneous anaphylaxis in mice. The test agents were orally administered for 5 days. Paeonia lactiflora extract, paeoniflorin and paeonol potently inhibited passive cutaneous anaphylaxis reaction and scratching behaviours in mice. Paeoniflorin exhibited the most potent inhibition against scratching behaviours and the acetic acid-induced writhing syndrome in mice. Paeonol most potently inhibited passive cutaneous anaphylaxis reaction and mast cells degranulation.
Assessor's comments
The results hint to an anti-allergic effect of the herbal substance, but are of limited clinical relevance as the tested dose is unclear, as the DER of the extracts and the dosages are not described clearly. Paeoniflorin is only a component of the root, so the results are limited for conclusions on clinical relevance.
Paeoniflorin
Chen Y et al. (2007) analysed the effects of paeoniflorin on the level of antibodies and cAMP produced by splenocytes in rats with adjuvant arthritis. Paeoniflorin (25, 50, and 100 mg/kg bw) were given by intragastric administration for 7 days from the 17 day after immunization. Paeoniflorin (50 and 100 mg/kg bw) reduced the levels of circulating immune complexes, anti-C II antibody and anti-TB antibody in serum in rats with adjuvant arthritis. The inhibition ratios were dosage dependent. Paeoniflorin (12.5, 62.5 and 312.5 mg/l) decreased the elevated levels of cAMP in spelnocytes in-vitro. (Chinese, only English abstract).
Total glycosides of peony
Li CL et al. (2013) examined the effects of total glucosides (100 mg /kg/day intragastrically) of peony for delaying onset of Sjogren's syndrome in an animal study using non-obese diabetic mice model. Compared to normal saline group, in TGP group saliva flow rate, submandibular glands index and the ration of regulatory T cells were significant higher, while anti-SSA/SSB and lymphocytic foci were significant lower. TGP demonstrated a similar effectiveness as hydroxychloroquine in delaying the onset of Sjogren's like disease in mice.
In-vitro
Total glycosides of peony
Jia et al.(2012) showed, that total glucosides of peony in 1562.5 pg/ml regulates cytokines production in lupus CD4+ T cells from systemic lupus erythematosus patients. IL-10 mRNA and protein levels were increased, in contrast the mRNA levels of IL-6 and IL-17A significantly decreased.
Zhao M et al. (2012) examined the molecular mechanism of TGP in prevention of autoimmune response. They found, total glucosides of peony (1562.5 pg/ml) induces regulatory CD4(+)CD25(+) T cells by increasing Foxp3 demethylation in lupus CD4(+) T cells. The IFN-y andIL-2 expression was enhanced in TGP treated lupus CD4 T cells.
Methanolic extract
Leem et al. (2004) tested Paeonia lactiflora root extracts on the secretions of chemokines as monocyte chemotactic protein-1 and -3 in human nasal fibroblasts. The extract significantly decreased the secretion of MCP-1 and MCP-3. The authors concluded Paeonia lactiflora may play a role in nasal inflammation.
Paeoniflorin
Tsuboi et al.(2004) investigated whether paeoniflorin induces DNA fragmentation in murine T lymphocytes and human T-cell leukemia Jurkat cells. Paeoniflorin induces fragmentation of DNA in murine thymocytes, spleen cells, splenic T-cells and Jurkat cells in a concentration dependent manner. DNA fragmentation was also induced in some but not all non-T-cell lines. The results suggest that sensitivity of paeoniflorin depends on cell type and that T-lineage cells are included in the highly sensitive group.
Yang L et al. (2013) conducted a comparative study on bioactivities of Paeoniae radix alba and Paeoniae radix rubra. The authors concluded Paeoniae radix alba and its major compounds possess more significant bioactivities on J774 macrophage cells than Paeoniae radix rubra and its major compounds, and the herbal substances should be classified into different category in TCM.
|
Paeoniae radix alba |
Paeoniae radix rubra | |
|
LPS induced inflammation |
Cell viability enhaced:1 mg/ml |
Cell viability inhibited 1 mg/ml |
|
Cell proliferation |
Activated by 1 mg/ml |
Inhibited by 1 mg/ml |
|
Early cell apoptosis |
Higher increase |
increase |
|
LPS production in J774 cells |
0.1 and 1 mg/ml reduce NO production |
0.1 and 1 mg/ml reduce NO production |
Assessor's comments
No experimental study was conducted with aqueous extract/tea preparations. The in-vitro experiments were conducted in concentrations of 1562.5 pg/ml TGP. For in-vitro data it should be kept in mind that for clear effects seen in concentrations of >100 pg/ml a physiological correlation is not plausible. Dose dependent effects of paeoniflorin on the level of antibodies could be shown in-vivo. The tested substance Paeoniflorin is only a component of the root. The results are limited for conclusions on clinical relevance of aqueous extracts.
Anticoagulant and antiplatelet activity
In-vivo
Aqueous extract of Paeonia lactiflora Pall.
Ishida et al. (1987) measured the plasma recalcification time in mice, what was find to be useful for following the anticoagulative activity and isolated the active principles as paeoniflorin and benzoylpaeoniflorin.
Different fractions of an methanolic extract
Kang et al. (1991) analysed platelet anti-aggregation of peony root. The ethylacetate soluble fraction showed strong inhibition at the concentration of 1 mg/ml against collagen or arachidonic acid induced aggregation and at 3 mg against ADP induced aggregation. Aqueous fraction did not inhibit the platelet aggregation.
Paeoniflorin
Ye J et al. (2001) evaluated the anti-thrombosis effect of paeoniflorin in a photochemical reaction thrombosis model in-vivo in rats. The time of the beginning of the irradiation to the occlusion of the vein was defined as the thrombosis time. Paeoniflorin injected in the mesenteric venue, could significantly prolong thrombosis time (no information about the used concentration). 10, 50, and 250 pg/ml increased tissue-type plasminogen activator (t-PA) activities in HUVEC. However, no significant effect was observed in plasminogen activator inhibitor (PAI) activity.
In-vitro
Koo et al. (2010) analysed the platelet anti-aggregatory and blood anti-coagulant effects of compounds isolated from Paeonia lactiflora and Paeonia suffruticosa by the turbidimetric method and measurement of coagulation time. Paeonol, paeoniflorin and benzoylpaeoniflorin were found to be the major common active constituents and they would collectively contribute to improving blood circulation.
In-vitro studies with unknown concentration of the substances paeoniflorin and benzoylpaeoniflorin hint to an anticoagulant and antiplatelet activity. As in-vivo paeoniflorinwas injected in the mesenteric venue, or missing information, no conclusion can be drawn for oral use and clinical effects. No preclinical studies were conducted with the aqueous plant extract.
Atherosclerosis effects
In-vitro
Paeoniflorin
Li JZ et al. (2013) found inhibitory effects of paeoniflorin on lysophosphatidylcholine-induced inflammatory factor production in human umbilical vein endothelial cells (HUVECs). The results suggest that PEP suppresses LPC-induced inflammatory factor production through inhibition of the HMGB1-RAGE/TLR-2/TLR-4-NF-KB pathway.
Aqueous extracts
Zhu et al. (2013) compared the chemical components between Baishao and Chishao aqueous extracts and their effects on proliferation of rat thoracic aorta smooth muscle cells. The results indicate the extracts have different chemical components and produce different biological effects. (Chinese, only English abstract)
In-vivo
Total glycosides of peony
Li J et al, (2011) analysed the effects of total glucosides from peony (Paeonia lactiflora Pall) roots (120 mg/kg, 240 mg/kg) intragastrically administered for 15 weeks on experimental atherosclerosis in rats. Compared to control, TGP significant lowered the serum level of total cholesterol, triglyceride, LDL-C, TNF-alpha, IL-6, C-reactive protein increased the ratios of HDL-C/LDL-C and ApoA1/ApoB, decreased the intima media-thickness of abdominal aortal wall and improved the morphological change of the aorta. The authors concluded the beneficial effects are associated with lowering blood lipids and inhibiting the expression of inflammatory cytokines.
Assessor's comments
In-vivo studies with oral administered TGP hint to atherosclerosis effects. No preclinical studies were conducted with the aqueous plant extract.
Antiviral activity
In-vitro
Aqueous extract from Paeonia veitchii L and Paeonia lactiflora Pall.
Guo et al, (2006) analysed in an in-vitro screening 16 aqueous extracts (20 g herbal substance boiled in 1000 ml water) of traditionally used medicinal plants in China against enteroviruses. Both Paeonia herbal preparations exhibited the strongest anti-Coxackie virus B3 activity on viral replication. Paeonia veitchii possessed an EC50 of >500.0 (mg/L).
Aqueous extract
Lin TJ et al. (2013) tested the anti-viral activity of decoct of Paeonia lactiflora pallas (100 g herbal substance was decocted with 1000 ml water three times, decoctions collected, mixed, concentrated, no DER information of the final extract) against human respiratory syncytial virus in human respiratory
tract cell lines. The final concentration was at 10, 30, 100 and 300 mg/ml for bioactivity assay and up to 3000 pg/ml for cytotoxicity test. Paeonia lactiflora decoct was time-dependently and dose-dependently effective against HRSV in Hep-2 and A549 cells. 10pg/ml had a comparable anti-HRSV activity with 10 pg/ml ribavirin. Paeonia lactiflora was effective against viral penetration and stimulated IFN-B secretion.
Assessor's comments
In-vitro studies hint to an antiviral activity of aqueous extracts. As the extracts were concentrated (no information on the DER), a correlation to the human used tea doses and clinical relevance is not possible.
Antibacterial activity In-vitro
Methanolic extract from Paeoniae radix and its fractions
Im and Lee (2012) evaluated the nitric oxide production inhibitory effect and antibacterial activity of the methanol extract and fractions from Paeoniae radix. As a result the ethyl acetate fraction of the methanol extract showed the highest antibacterial activity and the ethyl acetate fraction in the highest nitric oxide production inhibitory effect. The aqueous fraction showed no activity in all the tests performed.
Steam distillate
Ngan et al. (2012) examined the inhibiting effects of Paeonia lactiflora root steam distillate constituents and structurally related compounds on human intestinal bacteria. The yield of the oil was 0.01% on dry weight basis of the root. Paeonia lactiflora root steam distillate was proven to have high growth-inhibiting activity against B. fragilis, B. thetaiotomicron, C. paraputrificum, S. typhimurium, and B. breve. Seven pure compounds were used in the study. The four major constituents were paeonol, myrtenol, myrtenal and (Z)-myrtenol. Paeonol, the major compound exhibited moderate to low growth-inhibiting activity against the test bacteria.
Ngan et al. (2012) found growth-inhibiting, bactericidal, and urease inhibitory effects of Paeonia lactiflora root constituents and related compounds on antibiotic-susceptible and resistant strains of Helicobacter pylori.
Assessor's comments
No preclinical studies were conducted with the aqueous plant extract. In-vitro studies with different lipophilic fractions and constituents of unknown concentrations hint to possible antibacterial effects. Clinical relevance cannot be concluded by the experiments.
Antifungal activity
Ethanolic extract of Paeoniae radix
Kim et al. (2009) analysed the antifungal activity of seven herbal plant extracts against five different Candida species by agar diffusion assay. The ethanolic extract (100% ethanol, no DER information) of Paeoniae radix showed no antifungal activity.
Anti-hyperlipidaemic effects In-vivo and in-vitro
Aqueous extract of Paeonia lactiflora Pallas radix
Goto et al. (1999) examined the effect of Paeoniae radix extract on endothelial function. The extract of Paeoniae radix was prepared by boiling in water. The yield was 11.0 g Paeoniae radix extract from 100 g of herbal substance. Male springue rats were divided in four groups: control group, high cholesterol diet group, low PRE group (high colesterol plus 60 mg /d Paeoniae radix extract ) and high Paeoniae radix extract group (high colesterol plus 360 mg /d extract). After 10 weeks of treatment, the body weights in high colesterol, low and high Paeoniae radix extract groups were significantly lower compared with that of the control group. Plasma total cholesterol level was significantly increased by about 9-10fold in the HC, low Paeoniae radix extract from and high Paeoniae radix extract from groups compared with the control group after 2 weeks. There were no differences in body weight, plasma total cholesterol and triglyceride levels among the high colesterol, low Paeoniae radix extract from and high Paeoniae radix extract groups. In endothelium-dependent relaxation to acetylcholine in aorta of rats, the relaxation of the high Paeoniae radix extract group was greater than the high colesterol and low Paeoniae radix extract group.
In-vivo
Paeoniflorin
Yang HO et al. (2004) isolated paeoniflorin from Paeonia lactiflora and analysed the antihyperlipidemic effect in experimentally induced hyperlipidemic rats. Paeoniflorin showed a lowering effect of total cholesterol, LDL and triglyceride levels compared with the control group at the dose of 200 and 400 mg/kg p.o. once a day for 4 weeks.
In-vitro
Paeoniflorin
Lin HR (2013) evaluated the activity of paeoniflorin against LXR by the mammalian one-hybrid and transient transfection reporter assays. Paeoniflorin (20-100 pM) transactivated GAL4 rat cholesterol 7 a-hydroxylase, phospholipid transferprotein and ATP-binding cassette A1 gene promotors in dose-dependent manner. The authors suggested paeoniflorin acts as a liver X receptor agonist.
Assessor's comments
In-vivo studies with oral administered paeoniflorin hint to a lowering effect of total cholesterol, LDL and triglyceride levels. Oral administered aqueous extract showed contrary results (Goto H et al., 1999). There were no differences in body weight, plasma total cholesterol and triglyceride levels among the high cholesterol group and peony radix extract groups. The yield was 11.0 g Paeoniae radix extract from (PRE) 100 g of herbal substance. The daily dose of 60 mg /d PRE and 360 mg /d PRE corresponds to 0.5 g/3.3 g herbal substance per rat of 350-380 g. The dose corresponds approximately 95 g (low dose)/632 g herbal substance (high dose) in a 70 kg human person and is higher than the human used doses in TCM.
Cardiovascular disorders In-vitro
Aqueous extract from Paeonia lactiflora
Goto et al. (1996) showed that an extract from Paeoniae Radix relaxed prostaglandin F2a precontracted aortic ring preparations of isolated rat aorta that contained endothelium. The active component was gallotannin. Paeoniflorin and paeonol lacked a vasodilator effect.
In-vivo
Total glycosides of peony
Long et al. (2012) analysed the cardioprotective effect of total peony glycosides against isoprenaline-induced myocardial ischemia in rats. Compared with model rats, TGP treatment (269.4 mg/kg intragastralic administration for 3 days before ISO administration and 449 mg/kg for 3 days after ISO administration) exhibited significantly reduced activities of GOT, LDH and CK, increased activity of SOD and lower levels of MDA. The protective effect of TGP treatment was even better than that of propranolol.
Paeonol and Paeonoflorin
Nizamutdinova et al. (2008) investigated the effect of paeonol and paeoniflorin, the main active principles of Paeonia albiflora, on myocardial ischemia/reperfusion injury in rats. Administration of 10 mg/kg paeoniflorin or paeonol i.p. 1 h prior to reperfusion injury resulted in a significant improvement of the hemodynamic parameters. The administration of paeoniflorin or paeonol reduced myocardial infarct size, through inhibition of apoptosis.
Assessor's comments
No preclinical studies were conducted with the aqueous plant extract. The experiments of Long et al. (2012) were performed with the isolated TGP in high doses (269.4 mg/kg intragastralic administration corresponds to 19 g TGP in a 70 kg person). Clinical relevance cannot be concluded by the experiments.
Anti-diabetic activity
In-vitro
Ethanolic extract of the root of Paeonia lactiflora Pallas
Juan et al. (2010) examined the anti-hyperglycemic effect of Paeoniae radix extract (95% ethanol, no DER information) via the transcriptional suppression of phosphoenopyruvate carboxykinase (PEPCK) in H4IIE cells of rats with streptozotozin-induced diabetes. The suppressive effects on hyperglycaemia and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase were dose and time-dependent. Paeonol and paeoniflorin did not suppress phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase expression at testing concentration.
Paeoniflorin
The results of Kong et al. (2013) showed effects of paeoniflorin on tumour necrosis factor-alpha-induced insulin resistance and changes of adipokines in 3T3-L1 adipocytes. Potential mechanism for the anti-inflammatory actions were suppression of the activation of IKK/NF-kB and JNK/SAPK which interrupt insulin signalling pathway and induce inflammatory factors expression, and enhancement of PPARy expression, which improves insulin signalling pathway and increases adiponectin expression.
No preclinical studies were conducted with the aqueous plant extract and no in-vivo studies are available. Clinical relevance cannot be concluded by the experiments.
Antitumor activity
In-vitro
Aqueous extract of Paeoniae radix alba
Kwon et al. (2006) investigated the mechanism of Paeoniae radix alba extract induced apoptosis in HL-60 leukemic cells. The results suggest, that Paeoniae radix alba extract -induced apoptosis is stimulated by release of cytochrome c to cytosol, by procaspase-9 processing and via a caspase-3 dependent mechanism. The extract is effective collapsing the mitochondrial membrane potential.
According Kwon et al. (2007) a lot of examples of the induction of apoptosis by nutritional supplements and herbs through the generation of reactive oxygen species exist. The authors concluded, however nutritional supplements and herbs must be used with caution, as few research studies have actually evaluated their safety and efficacy and no guidelines for dose and usage are available.
Paeoniae radix extract (no information on plant species, DES, extraction solvent)
Abdelhamed et al, (2013) screened 138 medicinal plant extracts in a concentration of 1 pg/ml against TRAIL-sensitive and insensitive TNBC cell lines MDA-MB-231 and MDA-MB 468. Among them only five plants did not cause apparent cytotoxicity as a single regimen but showed significant synergistic effects against both cell-lines. The paeonia plant extract did not meet the criteria.
Paeoniflorin
Fang S et al. (2012) reported that paeoniflorin may effectively modulate multidrug resistance of the human gastric cancer cell line SGC7901/vincristine via the inhibition of NF-kB activation and down regulation its target genes MDRI1, BCL-XL and BCL-2. It is suggested, that NF-kB activation may play a role in the development of chemotherapy resistance in carcinoma cells.
Aqueous extract of Paeonia lactiflora Pallas
Lee et al. (2002) examined the cell growth of HepG2 and Hep 3 B cells in the presence of various concentrations of Paeoniae radix extract. The Paeoniae radix extract inhibited hepatoma cells growth by inducing apoptosis in a p53 independent pathway at a concentration of 4.6 and 4.4 mg/ml. The PRE could induce the internucleosomal DNA fragmentation of HepG2 and Hep3B cells. The authors concluded it may be a promising anticancer agent for inhibiting the growth of p53-deficient tumours.
Monoterpene glycosides
Washida et al. (2009) isolated a new monoterpenes glycoside 3-O-galloylpaeoniflorin and four known compounds from Paeonia lactiflora roots, which showed androgen receptor binding activity. The activity of pentagalloylglucose was equivalent to flutamide (IC50 5.0 pmol). The authors proposed that pentagalloylglucose inhibits prostate cancer cell growth by acting as an androgen receptor antagonist.
In-vivo
Total glycosides of peony
Xu HY al. (2012) analysed the antitumor activity of total peony glycoside against human chronic myelocytic leukemia K562 cell lines in-vitro and in-vivo in nude mice. TGP (1.5 g/kg) or CTX (25 mg/kg) was administered via intraperitoneal injection every 4 days. At 32 days TGP showed a significant decreased tumour volume and tumour weight in nude mice inoculated with k562 cells.
For in-vitro data it should be kept in mind that for clear effects seen in concentrations of >100 pg/ml a physiological correlation is not plausible, so results with concentrations of 4.6 and 4.4 mg/ml are not convincing. In other in-vitro experiments the paeonia plant extract did not meet the criteria for effectiveness. No in-vivo experiments were conducted with aqueous extracts. From in-vivo experiments via intraperitoneal injection cannot be drawn any conclusion for oral use.
Cerebral ischaemia and cognitive effects
In-vivo
Paeoniflorin-derivates
Abdel-Hafez et al. (1998) evaluated 8 paeoniflorin-derivates on their effect on the memory deficits induced by scopolamine using a step-down type of a passive avoidance task in mice at concentrations of 0.002-0.02 mmol/kg. The results indicated that full methylation in the chemical structure significantly enhanced the ameliorating effect. No correlation to the natural concentration of the derivates in the plant was given. The authors assumed further clarification is necessary for (chemical) design of more potent candidates.
Paeoniflorin
Liang Xiao et al. (2005) examined the effects of paeoniflorin on the cerebral infarction, behavioural and cognitive impairments at the chronic stage of transient middle cerebral artery occlusion in rats. One day (10 mg/kg twice s.c.) or seven-day (2.5 x 10 mg/kg, twice a day, s.c) injection of paeoniflorin significantly reduced the infarct volume as well as ameliorated the deficits in neurological symptoms caused by transient middle cerebral artery occlusion at chronic stage.
Tang et al. (2010) tested the anti-inflammatory effect of paeoniflorin (10 mg/kg intravenously) on cerebral infarction induced by ischemia-reperfusion injury in Sprague-Dawley rats. The results indicated that both pre-treatment and post-treatment with paeoniflorin reduced the ratio of cerebral infarction area. Pre-treatment also reduce the neurological deficit score.
Total glycosides of peony
Liu et al. (2004) analysed the protective effect of TGP on complete cerebral ischemia reperfusion injury in rats. TGP (20 mg/kg) possessed protective effects on the histopathological changes of ischemia cerebral tissues in rats. (Chinese, only English abstract)
ZhangAP et al. (1993) showed that TGP, (50 mg/kg 7d, ig) could enhance the episode duration of slow-wave sleep in normal rats and restore the sleep parameters in the insomniac rats induced by caffeine (12.5 mg/kg 7d, ip). (Chinese, only English abstract)
Aqueous extract of peony root, paeoniflorin
Ohta et al. (1993) analysed the effect of four herbs Japanese angelica root, cnidium rhizome, peony root and rhemmania root on the scopolamine induced spatial working memory disruption in rats. Doses of the extracts were expressed as dried herb weight per kg body weight. Among the component herbs, disruption of the choice accuracy peony root extract (corresponding 0.25 and 1 g dried herb/kg, orally) exhibited the most antagonizing effect on the scopolamine. Paeoniflorin (0.01-1 mg/kg, PO) dose-dependent attenuated the scopolamine-induced impairment in the choice accuracy.
Aqueous extract of peony root
Tsuda et al. (1997) evaluated the protective effects of peony root aqueous extract (no DER information) and its components on neuron damage in the hippocampus induced by the cobalt focus epilepsy model in rats. Neuron damage in the CA1 area of the hippocampus and frequent spike discharges induced by application of metallic cobalt to the cerebral cortex of rats were completely prevented when the extract was continuously administered orally at 1 g/kg/day for 30 days prior to cobalt application. The use of paeoniflorin alone had no effect. The gallotannin fraction had incomplete protective action. A combination of the gallotannin and paeoniflorin fraction showed complete action in the same way as peony root extract.
Total glycosides of peony
Yang J et al. (2000) analysed the protective effect of total peony glycoside against cerebral ischemia-reperfusion injury model in mice. TGP could improve the learning and memory capacity of model mice in step down test. (Chinese, only English abstract)
Yang J et al. (2001) analysed the protective effects of total peony glycoside on cerebral ischemia mice. TGP could prolong gasp time of decapatative mice, lessen cerebral water content and decrease permeability of cerebral capillary significantly. (Chinese, only English abstract)
Yang J et al. (2000) analysed the improvement effects of total peony glycoside on ability of learning and memory in model mice induced by medicinal products. TGP could reduce irritated time, prolonged duration of safe staying, lessen the times of error and adjust latent duration. In model mice of spatial resolution TGP increased ratio of successful landing, reduced times of mistake and lessoned the time of landing. (Chinese, only english abstract)
Assessor's comments
Neuron damage in the CA1 area of the hippocampus and frequent spike discharges induced by application of metallic cobalt to the cerebral cortex of rats were prevented when an aqueous extract was continuously administered orally. In disruption of the choice accuracy, peony root extract exhibited antagonizing effect on the scopolamine. The doses correspond to 17.5-70 g dried herb for a 70 kg person and hint to possible effects.
Gastrointestinal activity
In-vitro
Pentagalloylglucose
Ono et al. (2000) found that Pentagalloylglucose, an antisecretory component of Paeoniae radix, inhibits gastric H+, K+-ATPase with an IC50 of 166 nmol/l and may be responsible for inhibition of acid secretion by Paeoniae radix.
Liver protective activity
In-vivo
Total glucosides of peony
Results of a study in rats by Dai LM et al. (1993) showed that pre-treatment with TGP (10, 20, mg/kg/d x 7d, ip) diminished the hepato-cellular degeneration and necrosis induced by D-Galactosamine or CCl4. (Chinese, only English abstract).
Wang H et al. (2005) evaluated effects of total glucosides of peony (60 and 120 mg/kg, oral) on immunological hepatic fibrosis in rats. Histological results showed that TGP improved the human albumin-induced alterations in the liver structure, alleviate lobular necrosis and significantly lowered collagen content.
Zheng LY et al. (2008) concluded by their study results total glucosides of peony (0.15 g/kg bw, 0.05 g/kg bw, intragastric) may protect liver function and modulate serum lipid for the fatty liver rats caused by insulin resistance, and its action mechanism may be concerned with enhancing sensitivity and antioxidative ability, decreasing serum lipid.
Paeoniflorin
Li et al. (2009, 2010) investigated the effects of paeoniflorin on hepatic fibrosis of mice infected with S. japonicum. Paeoniflorin was administrated orally on the 12th day (30 days of successive administration) after infection. Paeoniflorin (30 mg/kg/day) ameliorates schistosomiasis liver fibrosis through regulating IL-13 and its signalling molecules in mice.
Paeoniae radix rubra and Paeoniae radix alba alcoholic extract
Wang R et al. (2012) found, that oral administered Paeoniae radix rubra and Paeoniae radix alba extract (12 g/ kg for 6 days, no DER information) attenuate CCl 4 -induced acute liver injury in rats. The extracts reduced the serum levels of several bile acids while they increased the serum levels of choline and 5-methylenetetrahydrofolate.
In-vitro
Ethanolic extract
The results of Kuo et al. (2012) in the in-vitro experiment in rat HSCs and LX-2, a human HSC cell line, show Paeoniae radix extract (80% ethanol) and its active components paeonol reduces PDGF-stimulated hepatic stellate cell migration. Hepatic stellate cells play a key role in the pathogenesis of liver fibroses.
Assessor's comments
The experiments of Wang R et al. (2012) were performed with ethanolic extracts in high doses (12 g/kg corresponding to 840 g in a 70 kg person). Total glucosides of peony, what are isolated substances of peony, may protect liver function and modulate serum lipids in-vivo. No preclinical studies were conducted with the aqueous plant extract. Clinical relevance cannot be concluded by the experiments.
Lung protective activity In-vivo
Paeoniflorin
Ji et al. (2013) found paeoniflorinattenuated bleomycin-induced pulmonary fibrosis in mice by suppressing the synthesis of type I collagen via inhibiting the activation of TGF-8/Smad pathway and increasing the expression of IFN-y. In mice orally treated with bleomycin consecutive 21 days, paeoniflorin (50 mg/kg) significantly prolonged the survival periods.
Assessor's comments
No experiments were conducted with preparations of the whole herbal substance, but only from isolated substances. Clinical relevance cannot be concluded by the experiments.
Neuroprotective activity
In-vitro
Paeoniflorin
Cao BY et al. (2010) evaluate a neuroprotective effect of paeoniflorin and found that paeoniflorin (50 pM) protects PC12 cells from MPP and acidic damage via autophagic pathway.
Methanolic extract
Lee et al. (2008) examined the protective effects of Paeonia lactiflora pall on hydrogen peroxide-induced apoptosis in PC12 cells. The total phenolic content was 89.65 mg per g of extract. After 2h of cell exposure to 0.5 mM H2O2 a marked reduction in cell survival was observed in the MTT reduction assay and LDH release assay.
In-vivo
Aqueous extract
Chen et al, (2011) found that Paeoniae alba radix aqueous extract (no DER information) caused enhancement of the nerve growth factor-mediated neurite outgrowth from PC12 cells as well as their expression of growth associated protein and synapsin I in-vitro. In the in-vivo study silicon rubber chamber filled with PR aqueous extract were used to bridge a 10-mm sciatic nerve defect in rats. At the conclusion of 8 weeks, regenerated nerves in the PR groups had a higher rate of successful regeneration across the wide gap, relatively larger mean values of total nerve area, myelinated axon, count and blood vessel number and significantly larger nerve conductive velocity compared to the control group.
Paeoniflorin
in rat both
Liu et al. (2005) examined the neuroprotective effect of paeoniflorin on transient ischemic model by activating adenosine A1 receptor in a manner different from its classical agonists. The administration of paeoniflorin (2.5 and 5 mg/kg bw s.c.) produced a dose-dependent decrease in neurological impairment and the histologically measured infarction volume. Similar results were obtained when paeoniflorin was given in permanent ischemia model.
Assessor's comments
No in-vivo experiments were conducted with oral administered extracts.
Uterine activity In-vivo
Methanolic extract of peony root
Harada et al. (1984) analysed the effects of Japanese Angelica root and peony root extracts (3g/kg, no DER information) on uterine contraction in the rabbit in situ. Intra-duodenal administration increased uterine activities. In some animal preparations inhibiting effect of the extracts on uterine contraction was noted after the uterotonic effect terminated.
"Crude alcoholic extract"
Madari and Robert (2004) reported, Paeonia officinalis was used in traditional medicine of ancient Persia as abortificient. A crude alcohol extract of the root of Paeonia officinalis produced uterine stimulation in rat confirming the traditional use as abortificant.
Assessor's comments
There is no information on the dosages used for abortification in the report of Madari (2004). The invivo experiments of Harada (1984) were conducted with very high doses 3 g/ kg corresponding to 210 g herb for a 70 kg person, so no conclusions for clinical relevance can be drawn. The possible effect should be considered for safety reasons.
Antioxidant activity In-vitro
Paeoniflorin
Chen T et al. (2011) analysed the protective effects of paeoniflorin extracted by Paeonia lactiflora Pall. against hydrogen peroxide-induced oxidative stress in human umbilical vein endothelial cells (HUVECs). Paeoniflorin increased significantly the percent cell viability of HUVECs injured by H2O2 using the MTT assay. By flow cytometric analyses paeoniflorin attenuated H2O2 induced apoptosis and intracellular reactive oxygen species production.
Methanol extract
Lee and Im (2011) analysed the tyrosinase inhibitory activity and melanin production inhibitory activity of the methanol extract and fractions from Paeoniae radix. The total polyphenol content of the methanol extract was 73.45 mg/g. The tyrosinase inhibitory activity of the ethyl acetate fraction showed higher activity than arbutin used as a positive control. In nontoxic concentration range, the ethylacetate fraction showed strong melanin production inhibitory effect and the authors considered it could be applicable to functional materials for skin-whitening agents.
In-vivo and in-vitro
Ethanolic extract
The results of the experiments of Lee et al. (2005) showed, the oral administration of 50% ethanol extract of peony root (no DER information), gallic acid and methyl gallate potently inhibited the formation of micronucleated reticulocytes in the mouse peripheral blood induced by a KBrO3 treatment in-vivo. The ethanolic extract exhibited a significant free radical scavenging effect against DPPH radical generation and had an inhibitory effect on lipid peroxidation as measured by the level of malondialdehyde formation.
Effect on renal tubule-interstitium in rats
In-vivo
Total glucosides of peony (TGP)
Fang F et al. (2008) administered TGP 50, 100, 200 mg/kg/d orally once a day for 8 weeks in diabetic rats. Increased indices for tubulointerstitial injury were significantly ameliorated by TGP treatment with 100 and 200 mg/kg bw. Elevated expression of osteopontin protein was inhibited with 100 and 200 mg/kg bw, and increased expression of a-smooth muscle actin with 50, 100, and 200 mg/kg bw.
Zhang C-Q et al. (2014) examined the effect of total glucosides of peony on TLR signal pathway in the kidney from diabetic rats. TGP 50, 100, 200 mg/kg/d was administered orally once a day for 8 weeks in diabetic rats. Western blot analysis showed, that the increased levels of TLR2, TLR4, MyD88, p-IRAK1, p-IRF3 and NF-kB p65 in the kidneys of diabetic rat were significantly suppressed by TGP treatment.
TGP
Wu et al. (2009) analysed the renoprotective effect of total glucosides of peony (TGP) and its mechanism in streptozotocin-induced diabetic rats. The rats were treated orally with TGP for 8 weeks. Treatment at 50, 100 and 200 mg/kg significantly lowered 24-h urinary albumin excretion rate. 100 and 200 mg/kg reduced indices for tubolointerstitial injury in diabetic rats.
No in-vivo experiments were conducted with oral administered extracts. The in-vivo experiments with orally administered TGP hint to a renoprotective effect for very high doses of isolated substances of peony radix. The clinical relevance is unknown.
Wound healing effect
In-vivo
Aqueous extract
Malviya and Jain (2009) examined the wound healing activity of aqueous extract (no further information) of Paeoniae radix by incision, incision and dead space wound models on Wistar rats. The results indicated that radix Paeoniae extract accelerates the wound healing process by decreasing the surface area of the wound and increasing the tensile strength. The histological examination of the granulation tissue of treated group showed increased cross-linking of collagen fibres and absence of monocytes.
Anti-depressant-like effect In-vivo
TGP
Mao et al. (2009) examined the effects of peony glycosides on mice exposed to chronic unpredictable stress. Chronic unpredictable stress induced depression, as indicated by increase in immobility time in the tail suspension test, was alleviated by s.c. administered TGP (160 mg/kg). The authors suggest the effect is probably mediated by inhibition of monoamine oxidation.
Mao et al. (2012) found that peony glycosides (160 mg/kg, sx.) reverse the effects of corticosterone on rats. Depression-like behavior was suppressed and brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) expression was increased in the rat model.
In a mini-review Mao et al. (2012) summarised the results of literature regarding the anti-depressantlike effect. The peony extract was active in the mouse forced swim test and tail suspension test, and produced anti-depressant effects in chronic unpredictable mild stress-induced depression model in mice and rats. The mechanisms of peony were likely mediated by the inhibition of monoamine oxidase activity, neuroprotection, modulation of the function of hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis, inhibition of oxidative stress and the up-regulation of neurotrophins.
Assessor's comments
The experiments were performed s.c. TGP. No in-vivo experiments were conducted with orally administered (aqueous extracts, decoction).
Blood enriching
In-vivo
Zhang JJ et al. (2013) conducted a comparative study on effects of blood enriching on mouse model of blood deficiency syndrome induced by compound method of bleeding, starved feeding and exhausting of Paeoniae radix alba and Paeoniae radix rubra (2 g/kg bw, no information on preparation) paeoniflorin and albiflorin. At the 7th day Paeonia radix alba has a better effect of blood enriching than Paeoniae radix rubra. Albiflorin was more effective than paeoniflorin.
It is unclear what preparation or the crude herbal substance was administered. The dose of 2 g/kg corresponds to 140 g for a 70 kg person and is higher as traditionally (TCM) used dosage ranges.
Effect on colitis
In-vivo
Paeoniflorin
Zhou et al. (2010) found that Paeoniflorin increases beta-defensin expression and attenuates lesion in the colonic mucosa from mice with oxazolone-induced colitis through regulating the expression of HBD-2, IL-6 and IL-10. (English abstract only).
3.1.2. Secondary pharmacodynamics
3.1.3. Safety pharmacology
Not available.
3.1.4. Pharmacodynamic interactions
3.1.5. Conclusions
The preclinical studies were often performed with isolated substances as paeoniflorin or TGP. Wang C et al. (2012) reported, when administered orally, paeoniflorin was absorbed poorly in gastrointestinal tract, leading to a very low bioavailability of 3-4%. So experiments with paeoniflorin are considered of minor relevance. Aqueous extracts were often administered over the doses ranges known from the TCM. Often no information on the DER of the final administered extracts was available.
Clinical relevance cannot be concluded from preclinical experiments and pharmacological data. No therapeutic posology in humans is known for the use in Europa. In summary, existing data are not adequate to support establishment of a European Union monograph.
3.2. Overview of available pharmacokinetic data regarding the herbal substance(s), herbal preparation(s) and relevant constituents thereof
Absorption
In-vitro: rat everted gut sacs
Paeoniflorin
Dong et al. (2009) showed that the absorption of paeoniflorin was linearity at different intestine segment and dose, and the square of degrees correlation coefficient exceed 0.9, which consistent with zero order rate process. The Ka of paeoniflorin showed a dose-dependent increase along with the raised dose of extractive Paeoniae radix alba, indicated it was a mechanism of passive absorption. (English abstract only)
Tan et al. (2011) tested the absorption ingredients of three concentration of Paeoniae radix alba in-vitro-everted intestinal sac (VEIS). Albiflorin and Paeoniflorin were the linear absorption (R2>0.9),
conformed to the zero order absorption rate. The values in Ka in the jejunum and ileum were increased along with the raised dosage, indicating a passive absorption manner. (Chinese, only English abstract)
In-vivo: rats
Pharmacokinetic comparison between Paeoniae radix rubra and Paeoniae radix alba
Wang CH et al. (2008) conducted a comparative pharmacokinetic study of paeoniflorin after oral administration of decoction of Paeoniae radix rubra and Paeoniae radix alba in rats. There was a significant difference between the pharmacokinetic characteristics of Paeoniflorin alone, Paeoniae radix rubra and Paeoniae radix alba (3.24%, 4.26% and 1.82%). The results suggested that the bioavailability of paeoniflorin in rats after oral administration was very low, about 3%. The Tmax, AUC0-ra, Cmax were increased after oral consumption of Paeoniae radix rubra compared to Paeoniae radix alba.
Feng et al. (2010) showed there was significant difference between the pharmacokinetic characteristics of Paeoniae radix rubra and Paeoniae radix alba by the HPLC-ESI-MS method. Aqueous solutions of the herbal substances were given to rats at a dose of containing 0.2 g/g crude herbal substance to rats.
|
Paeoniae radix rubra |
Paeoniae radix alba | |
|
Cmax paeoniflorin |
185.24±26.24 ng/ml |
34.44±13.43 ng/ml |
|
AUC 0-ra paeoniflorin |
52.274.73±489.32 ng h/ml |
315.08±85.44 ng h/ml |
|
Tmax paeoniflorin |
0.67±0.07 ng/ml |
0.33±0.02 ng/ml |
|
T1/2 paeoniflorin |
1.86±0.27 |
0.85±0.11 |
The increase of AUC suggested, paeoniflorin was absorbed better from the decoction of Paeoniae radix rubra e than in from Paeoniae radix alba e. The longer Tmax and T1/2 implied the delay of absorption and slower of elimination of paeoniflorin.
Hsiu et al. (2003) investigated the metabolism and pharmacokinetics of paeoniflorin by oral administration in rats. The paeoniflorin levels in serum were below the detection limit through the study. In conclusion paeoniflorin was not absorbed per se, whereas its aglycone paeoniflorigenin was absorbable and circulating in the bloodstream.
Tang and Eisenbrand reported in the Handbook of Chinese Medicinal Plants, Chemistry, Pharmacology, Toxicology (2011) that paeoniflorin seemed to be poorly absorbed from the gastrointestinal tract, resulting in an extremely low bioavailability.
Wang C et al. (2012) reported, according previous studies, when administered orally, paeoniflorin was absorbed poorly in gastrointestinal tract, leading to a very low bioavailability of 3-4 %. The causes of paeoniflorin's poor bioavailability are poor permeation efflux via P-glycoprotein and hydrolytic degradation by esterase in the intestine. Therefore they compared the pharmacokinetics of paeoniflorin microemulsion with paeoniflorin saline after repeated dosing in rats with adjuvant arthritis. The plasma concentration of 25, 50 mg/kg were undetectable by the HPLC assay. The AUC0-1, the mean retention time and the Cmax were increased in the 100 mg/kg microemulsion group, indicating a better absorption of the formula.
Distribution
In-vivo: mice
Paeoniflorin
Chen L-C (1999) administered orally peony radix extracts to mice (24.6 g dry extract obtained from 200 g crude material; extraction solvent aqueous) at a dose of 10 mg/kg paeoniflorin for quantification of paeoniflorin. The calibration curve for paeoniflorin was linear over the concentration range 10-200 ng/ml. The recoveries of paeoniflorin from mice plasma were found to be 74.49, 76.83, 80.38, and 80.56% for concentrations of 30, 80, 120, and 160 ng/ml respectively. The plasma concentration-time curves fitted with mean terminal half-lives of 94.16 min.
Cao et al. (2006) determined the paeoniflorin concentration in the cortex of normal and cerebral ischemia-reperfusion rats and plotted the time course profile in rat cortex. Paeoniflorin could quickly penetrate through the blood-brain barrier after intravenous administration in a dose of 60 mg/kg bw. The cortex concentration in ischemia-reperfusion rats were lower 5 min after dosing and declined more slowly than in normal control.
Radix Paeoniae alba (aqueous-) extract
Li et al. (2011) analysed the pharmacokinetic properties of albiflorin and paeoniflorin after oral administration of pure compound, Paeoniae radix alba extract and danggui-shaoyao-san extract (composed of 7 plants) to rats. After oral administration of Paeoniae radix alba extract and danggui-shaoyao-san extract albiflorin reached maximum concentrations of 4637±2774 ng/ml and 226±122 mg/ml and PAE 2132±569 ng/ml and 143±65 ng/ml respectively. Compared to the AUC0-t value for albiflorin and paeoniflorin after administration of monomers, larger value of albiflorin and paeoniflorin after administration of Paeoniae radix alba extract (10 g/kg bw) and smaller value after administration of DSS (10 g/kg bw) extract were obtained.
Sun et al. (1996) reported Glycosidases, produced in E. coli as a cytoplasmic protein, convert natural glycosides to bioactive compounds. Paeoniflorin was biotransformed to paeonimetabolins I and II.
While paeoniflorin shows depressant, antispasmodic and anti-inflammatory effects, the paeonometabolin I showed anticonvulsive effects, which was interpreted as increased pharmacological activity.
Elimination
Dried powder of Paeoniae radix alba
Chen et al. (2014): The extract of Paeoniae radix alba (50.0 g herbal substance extracted in 400 ml water, 2 times for each 2 hours, diverse follow up processes,) was given orally at a dose of 3 g/kg (corr. 18.75 g/kg for crude herbal substance) daily in rats. A total of 65 compounds were detected in rat bile, plasma and urine samples including 11 parent compounds and 54 metabolites. The results indicated that glucuronidation, hydroxylation and methylation were major metabolic pathways of the components of Paeoniae radix alba extract.
Pharmacokinetic interactions
In-vivo
Aqueous extracts
Chen LC et al. (2002) analysed the pharmacokinetic interactions between carbamazepine and Paeoniae radix (Paeonia lactiflora) extracts (300 mg/kg; 24.6 g extract weighting from 200 g of raw material by decoct and drying) in rats. The significant decrease of Tmax indicated that simultaneous oral
administration of PR contributes to more rapid absorption of CBZ. A significant decrease in protein binding rate was found (62.7 and 68.1%), what was considered probably free from clinical consequences because the wide fluctuations in carbamazepine concentrations between doses. There were no changes in AUC, T^2, Cmax.
Chen LC et al. (2001) analysed the pharmacokinetic interactions between phenytoin (PHT) and Paeoniae radix (Paeonia lactiflora) extracts (300 mg/kg; 24.6 g extract weighting from 200 g of raw material by decoct and drying) in rats. The significant increase of Tmax indicated that simultaneous oral administration of PR delayed the absorption of PHT. No significant decrease in protein binding rate was found. There were no changes in AUC, Ti/2, Cmax, MRT, CL/F of phenytoin.
In-vitro
Paeoniflorin
Dong et al. (2009) showed, paeoniflorin is a substrate of P-glycoprotein, and extractive Paeoniae radix alba could induce expression of the P-glycoprotein in-vitro in the everted gut sac model. (Chinese, only abstract in English)
3.3. Overview of available toxicological data regarding the herbal substance(s)/herbal preparation(s) and constituents thereof
3.3.1. Single dose toxicity
In-vivo
Water solubel extraction of Paeoniae radix alba
Huang et al. (2012) evaluated the toxicity of paeoniflorin sulfonate by in-vitro cytotoxicity carried out on mouse and human primary hepatodytes and by acute oral toxicity test carried out on mice. Paeoniflorin sulfonate does not have any cytotoxicity to cells at all the tested concentrations (<300^mol/L) in the in-vitro cytotoxicity assay. The maximum tolerance dose of paeoniflin sulfonate solution and water solubel extraction of Paeoniae radix alba to mouse was 5 g/kg and 80 g/kg respectively (nor further information on DER).
3.3.2. Repeat dose toxicity
3.3.3. Genotoxicity
Ethanolic extracts of Paeonia lactiflora Pallas and Paeoniae radix rubra (P. albiflora var. hortensis Makino)
Chang et al. (1989) examined 40 Chinese herbal drugs for mutagenicity in the SOS chromotest (E. coli PQ37) and in the SOS umu test. The ethanolic herbal extracts in 4 mg/ml showed no mutagenicity.
Aqueous extracts of Paeonia lactiflora Pallas and Paeoniae radix rubra (P. albiflora var. hortensis Makino)
Chang et al. (1989) examined 40 Chinese herbal drugs for mutagenicity in the SOS chromotest (E. coli PQ37) and in the SOS umu test.
The results of the aqueous extracts of Paeonia lactiflora were not presented. The authors assumed, non of the 40 Chinese herbal drugs seem to exhibit mutagenic activities under the experimental
conditions. The aqueous extracts of Paeoniae radix rubra (P. albiflora var. hortensis Makino) in 4mg/ml and 50 mg/ml showed no mutagenicity in the SOS umu test (-S9: 82; +S9: 69 versus-S9:
38;+S9:72; mitomycin: 566 8-Galactosidase activity/unit). Aqueous extracts of Paeonia radix Paeoniae radix rubra (P. albiflora var. hortensis Makino) exhibited an antimutagenic activity against mitomycin C and aflatoxin B1 in SOS umu test.
Yu et al. (2004) examined the toxicological safety and stability of the components of an irradiated Korean medical herb, Paeoniae Radix. The mutagenicity of the aqueous extract was examined triplicatedly in Salmonella reversion assay at 5 dosages from 62 to 5000pg/plate. The number of revertant colonies of each strain in test group did not increased comparing with negative control group. The increase of the colony formation by irradiate sample was not appreciated in both direct non-activate and indirect activated tests. The extract did not show cytogenetic toxicity in the culture of the Chinese hamster ovary cells. The authors concluded, chronic toxicity tests are needed for public acceptance in the application of irradiation for the hygienic technology of the herbs.
3.3.4. Carcinogenicity
3.3.5. Reproductive and developmental toxicity
Not available.
3.3.6. Local tolerance
3.3.7. Other special studies
Harada et al. Y (1984) analysed the effects of Japanese Angelica root and Peony root extracts (3 g/kg, no DER information) on uterine contraction in the rabbit in situ. Intra-duodenal administration increased uterine activities. Madari H and Robert S. Jacobs (2004) reported Paeonia officinalis was used in traditional medicine of ancient Persia as abortificient. A crude alcohol extract of the root of Paeonia officinalis produced uterine stimulation in rat confirming the traditional use as abortifacient.
3.3.8. Conclusions
Only scarce toxicological data are available from literature. Adequate tests on genotoxicity, carcinogenicity, reproductive and developmental toxicity and local tolerance are not available. There are some hints for abortificient effects. Consequently, the use in pregnants should be contraindicated (also in the combination preparations of the TCM) for safety reasons.
3.4. Overall conclusions on non-clinical data
Non-clinical information on the safety of peony radix is scarce. The preclinical pharmacological data are not appropriate to document clear pharmacological actions for the aqueous extracts used in TCM. The scarce data available on single and repeated dose toxicity reveal no suspicion of safety concerns regarding human therapeutic TCM doses. There are some hints for abortifacient effects which should be considered for safety reasons. Test on carcinogenicity, reproductive and developmental toxicity and local tolerance are not available. Specific data on pharmacokinetics and interactions are not available.
Numerous publications on Paeoniae radix or constituents exist, however, often an appropriate description of herbal substance or herbal preparations used are missing. Available data are not sufficient to establish a European Union monograph.
4. Clinical Data
4.1. Clinical pharmacology
4.1.1. Overview of pharmacodynamic data regarding the herbal substance(s)/preparation(s) including data on relevant constituents
Total glucosides of peony
Lin J et al. (2012) treated 10 patients with diagnosis of rheumatoid arthritis with TGP by oral administration of 15 mg/kg/day more than 3 month, while another 10 RA patients did not take TGP. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells were obtained from patients by Ficoll-Hypaque separation. TGP treatment led to decreased percentage of matured DC and Th1/Th17 cells in peripheral blood of patients. The results were in accordance with the in-vivo tests in the model or CIA in mice. The authors conclude the results may explain the functions of TGP in reducing inflammation and immune response in autoimmune disease.
Wang Z-J (1994) reported improvements in immune function by total glycosides of peony in rheumatoid arthritis patients. (No further information, Chinese, only English abstract).
Liao Dun and Luo Quingfeng (2005) reported Baishao (Radix Paeoniae alba) had antispasmodic, painkilling and diuretic effect, which is particularly suitable for the treatment of chronic prostatitis.
4.1.2. Overview of pharmacokinetic data regarding the herbal substance(s)/preparation(s) including data on relevant constituents
Wang Z-J (2012) reported total glucosides of peony (TGP) contain more than 90% of paeoniflorin. Paeoniflorin was absorbed poorly in gastrointestinal tract, leading to a very low bioavailability (3-4%). TGPs slow effect seriously limited its application to RA patients (Liu DZ et al, 2005) und must be improved by novel formulations as microemulsions.
4.2. Clinical efficacy
According the review article "Peony" in Herbal Medicines (2013), there is limited reliable clinical information available for the pharmacological effects and its main constituents. Many studies are available where peony is combined with other herbs in TCM or TJM or given with conventional treatment, so that clinical information on the action of peony alone is generally not available and therefore the effects found cannot always be attributed to peony.
4.2.1. Dose response studies
Not available.
4.2.2. Clinical studies (case studies and clinical trials)
Patients with active rheumatoid arthritis
Total glucosides of peony of Paeonia lactiflora Pallas
Zhao YX and Liu (2006) conducted a clinical observation on effects of leflunomid (LEF) (no information on dose) and total glucosides of peony on patients with rheumatoid arthritis. 40 persons were treated with TGP and leflunomide and the control group of 40 persons was treated with LEF alone for 12 weeks. The total effective rate was higher in the treatment group than in the control group (97.5% vs 85.0%) without significant difference in adverse reactions.
Chen Z et al. (2013) analysed in a 24-week, open label, randomized clinical trial the efficacy of total glucosides of peony and the protective effect on hepatotoxicity in the combination treatment with methotrexate and leflunomide in 204 patients with active rheumatoid arthritis. No statistically significant differences were found.
Du and Dong (2005) analysed the clinical efficacy of methotrexate combined with TGP on rheumatoid arthritis for 3 months. 30 patients were only administered orally methotrexate, while 31 patients were treated with methotrexate plus TGP (no dose information). The total effective rate was 90%, 94% 100% in the methotrexate plus TGP group and 87%, 90% 94% in the methotrexate group at 4, 8 and 12 weeks. (Chinese, only English abstract)
Wang Y and Xing (2007) conducted a clinical observation on the effect of total glucosides of peony combined with methotrexate on rheumatoid arthritis for 24 weeks. Two hundred and sixty patients were assigned to two groups the treated group (180 cases) was orally administered with methotrexate and TGP (no information on dose) and the control group (80 cases) with methotrexate plus sulfasalazine. The total effective rate at the 4th, 8th, 12th,24th week of the treatment was 70%, 81%, 94%, 98% in the treated group and 60%, 85%, 93% and 94% respectively. The authors concluded TGP combined methotrexate treatment shows a quicker initiation with fewer side effects. (Chinese only English abstract).
Zhang W and Dai (2012) reported, a preparation of TGP was approved by State Food and Drug Administration of China to enter market as a disease-modifying drug for RA in 1998. However, there was no report available to show whether TGP treatment retard the radiographic progression of the disease.
Patients with psoriatic arthritis
Total glucosides of peony (TGP) of Paeonia lactiflora Pallas
Wang YN et al. (2014) analysed the beneficial effect of total glucosides of peony on psoriatic arthritis links to circulating Tregs and Th1 cell function in clinical observation study. 19 patients received 12-week-treatment 3x 600 mg TGP per day. Response was evaluated at 12 weeks, by determining whether at least a 25% reduction of disease activity score (DAS28) was met. Six patients (32%) exhibited >25% decrease of DAS28 and were defined as responder. All responders displayed a continuous decrease in Treg and Th1 numbers, concomitant with decrease in Th1-type cytokine levels and decrease in serum IL-6 levels. Non-responder lacked these alterations.
Patients with chronic urticaria
Total glycosides of peony
Long et al. (2010) conducted a clinical observation on the treatment of chronic urticaria with total glucosides of peony capsule combined with cetirizine to assess the effect and adverse reaction. A total of 120 patients were assigned to two groups by lottery, 65 in the treated group and 55 in the control group. They all were orally treated with cetirizine tablet 10 mg per day, but to the treated group, additional 0,2g TGPC was given three times per day. The therapeutic course for both groups was 4 weeks. The effectiveness of treatment was observed, and the changes of total symptom score, serum levels of interleukin-4 (IL-4), and immunoglobulin E (IgE) were measured before and after treatment. Moreover, a follow-up was carried out one month after ending the treatment.
RESULTS:
The dropped cases were two in the treated group and seven in the control group, so, the study was accomplished on 63 patients in the treated group and 48 patients in the control group. The total effective rate was assessed at 73.02% (46/63) in the treated group, which was significantly higher than 47.92% (23/48) in the control group (P<0.01). After treatment, the total symptom score decreased in both groups, but the decrement in the treated group was more significant (P<0.05). Serum levels of IL-4 and IgE in the treated group lowered significantly, while the changes in the control group were insignificant, so statistical significant differences were shown between groups (P<0.01). A follow-up study showed that the relapse rate in the treated group was 30.00% (6/20), while that in the control group was 90.00% (9/10), and the former was lower than the latter (P<0.01). Adverse reactions, revealed as drowsiness, dizziness, and weakness, were seen in eight cases and seven cases in the two groups, respectively. Besides, mild diarrhea occurred in two cases of the treated group. No toxicity on liver, kidney and nerve system was found.
The authors recommended more than 4 weeks medication, as through the observation in the first two weeks no relevant differences were between the groups. The symptom improving began in the latter two weeks of the treatment.
Patients with alopecia areata
Total glycosides of peony
Yang DQ et al. (2012) conducted a randomized controlled trial comparing total glucosides of peony capsule and compound glycyrrhizin tablet for alopecia areata 3 month long. A total of 86 outpatients were randomized into two groups. The TGP group of 44 patients received10 mg Vitamin B2 and three times 600 mg TGP daily. The control group received 3 times daily 50 mg glycyrrhizin. In the treatment group the cured and markedly effective rate was 36.36%, 50.00% and 68.18% at the end of the first, second and third month of treatment, versus 38.10%, 57.14% and 71.43% respectively. There was no statistic difference between the groups.
In the TGP group occurred 12 adverse reactions: 2x abdominal pain, 6 x loose stool and 4x increase of stool frequency. In the glycyrrhizin group occurred 14 adverse reactions: 2x hypokalemia, 3x increased blood pressure, 5x edema, 2x increased weight, 1x decrease in muscle strength.
Patients with Non-systemic Involved Sjögren Syndrome
Total glycosides of peony
Zhang HF et al. (2007) conducted a retrospective clinical observation on effect of total glucosides of peony in treating patients with non-systemic involved Sjögren syndrome. 27 patients received TGP and 20 patients received hydroxychoroquine (HCQs) for over 2 years. In the TGP group saliva secretion was significant increased from the 6th month, as in the HCQ group. Y-globulin decreased significantly from the 6th month in the TGP group and in the HCQ group from the 3th month. Mild diarrhea occurred in 4 cases in the TGP group, one case with severe diarrhea was dropped. In the HCQ group 2 patients were dropped because of sever adverse reactions. The authors concluded TGP has an equivalent efficacy to HCQ but a better safety. (Chinese, only English abstract)
Patients with systemic lupus erythematosus
Zhang HF et al. (2011) conducted a clinical study of total glucosides of peony in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus. 29 patients of the TGP1 group took orally TGP for 5 or more years. 47 patients took TGP for more than one year (TGP2 group). 20 Patients served as control. The average daily dose of prednisone, total CTX dose and SLE disease activity index were lower in the TGP1 group than in the TGP2 group. The average daily dose of prednisone, total CTX dose were lower in the TGP2 group than in the control group. The authors concluded TGP could reduce the average daily dose of prednisone and the total CTX dose especially for the medication of more than five years.
Table 3: Clinical studies on humans, in rheumatoid arthritis
|
Type |
Study |
Test Product(s) |
Number of subjects |
Subjects |
Outcomes |
Statistical analysis |
Clinical relevance |
|
Zhao YX and Liu |
clinical |
1. leflunomid |
Test group: |
Patients with |
The total effective rate was higher |
Only TGP | |
|
Y (2006) effects |
observation |
(LEF)(no |
40 persons |
rheumatoid |
in the treatment group than in the |
and not the | |
|
of leflunomid |
information on |
TGP and |
arthritis |
control group (97.5% vs 85.0%) |
whole plant | ||
|
(LEF) (no |
12 weeks |
dose) and total |
leflunomide |
without significant difference in |
(decoct) | ||
|
information on |
glucosides of |
control |
adverse reactions |
was | |||
|
dose) and total |
peony |
group: |
analysed | ||||
|
glucosides of |
2. leflunomid |
40 persons | |||||
|
peony on rheumatoid arthritis. |
LEF alone | ||||||
|
Chen et al. |
24-week, |
TGP group: |
204 |
Patients with |
Protective effect on hepatotoxicitv |
Mean |
Only TGP |
|
(2013), |
open label, |
MTX: 10 mg /week |
patients |
rheumatoid |
ALT>1.5 to<2 times= 1.9% vs |
standard |
and not the |
|
efficacy of total |
randomized |
LEF: 29 mg/day |
18-75 |
arthritis, |
10.1% TGP vs CG; |
deviation, |
whole plant |
|
glucosides of |
clinical trial |
TGP: 3x0.6 g daily |
years, |
disease active |
AST>2 to<3 times= |
median, t- |
(decoct) |
|
peony (TGP) and |
10 |
score in 28 |
2.9% vs 12.4% TGP vs CG; |
test, |
was | ||
|
the protective |
Control group: |
withdrew |
joints |
Elevated liver enzymes 3 times |
Mann- |
analysed; | |
|
effect on |
MTX: 10 mg /week |
the study |
(DAS28)>3.2. |
the ULN: 4.8% (TGP) and 12.4% |
Whitney U- |
No | |
|
hepatotoxicity in |
LEF: 29 mg/da |
TGP group: |
(CG) |
Test, |
statistically | ||
|
the combination |
TGP group: |
5.98±1.14 |
No statistically significant |
Kruskal- |
significant | ||
|
treatment with |
105 |
Control group |
difference |
Wallis-test |
differences; | ||
|
methotrexate |
Control |
(CG): |
Efficacy |
No placebo | |||
|
(MTX)and |
group:89 |
6.28±1.34 |
Reduction of the DAS28 values: |
group; | |||
|
leflunomide (LEF) |
TGP: 2.07±1.3 |
No | |||||
|
CG: 2.01 ±1.11 |
conclusion | ||||||
|
Patients with good or moderate |
on efficacy | ||||||
|
response at week 12: TGP: |
in patients | ||||||
|
81.9%; CG:74.6% |
with RA is | ||||||
|
No statistically significant |
possible |
|
Type |
Study |
Test Product(s) |
Number of subjects |
Subjects |
Outcomes |
Statistical analysis |
Clinical relevance |
|
difference | |||||||
|
Du J and Dong B |
3-month, |
No information |
31 patients |
Patients with |
The total effective rate was 90%, |
No placebo | |
|
(2005) efficacy of |
open label, |
TGP+MTX |
rheumatoid |
94% 100% in the MTX plus TGP |
group; | ||
|
total glucosides |
randomized |
30 Patients |
arthritis, |
group and 87%, 90% 94% in the | |||
|
of peony (TGP) in |
clinical trial |
MTX |
MTX group at 4, 8 and 12 weeks |
No | |||
|
the combination |
Insignificant difference (p>0.05) |
conclusion | |||||
|
treatment with |
on efficacy | ||||||
|
methotrexate |
in patients | ||||||
|
(MTX) |
with RA is | ||||||
|
possible | |||||||
|
Long JW et al. |
Clinical |
TGP aroup: |
120 |
Chronic |
The total effective rate: |
Only TGP | |
|
(2010): |
observation |
1x dailylO mg |
patients, |
urticarial for |
73.02% (46/63) in the treated |
and not the | |
|
treatment of |
cetirizine |
65 |
over 3 |
group, |
whole plant | ||
|
chronic urticaria |
3x 0,2 g TGP |
treatment |
months, |
47.92% (23/48) in the control |
(decoct) | ||
|
with total |
group |
16-60 years |
group (P<0.01) |
was | |||
|
glucosides of |
Cetirizin aroup |
55 control |
old, no other |
analysed; | |||
|
peony capsule |
lx daily 10 mg |
group |
treatment |
relapse rate |
no placebo | ||
|
combined with |
cetirizine |
treated group 30.00% (6/20), |
group. | ||||
|
cetirizine to |
control group 90.00% (9/10), | ||||||
|
assess the effect |
4 weeks treatment, |
Significant | |||||
|
and adverse |
4-weeks follow up |
IL-4 (ng/ml) treated group: |
differences | ||||
|
reaction |
Pre-treat.:151.23±31.00 |
in relapse | |||||
|
Post-treat: 105.97±9.52 |
rate hint to | ||||||
|
IL-4 control group: |
possible | ||||||
|
Pre-treat.:155.92±24.22 |
clinical | ||||||
|
Post-treat: 150.96±30.79 IgE (IU/ml) treatment group Pre-treat. : 1012.91±217.73 |
relevance |
|
Type |
Study |
Test Product(s) |
Number of subjects |
Subjects |
Outcomes |
Statistical analysis |
Clinical relevance |
|
Post-treat: 300.00±169.19 control group: Pre-treat.:997.54±252.40 Post-treat: 943.35±240.86 | |||||||
|
Wang Y and Xing HY (2007): efficacy of total glucosides of peony (TGP) in the combination treatment with methotrexate (MTX)on rheumatoid arthritis |
Clinical observation |
TGP group: MTX TGP Control group: MTX Sulfasalazine |
TGP group: 180 patients Control group: 80 patients |
Patients with rheumatoid arthritis |
total effective rate at the 4th, 8th, 12th,24th week of the treatment TGP group 70%, 81%, 94%, 98% Control group 60%, 85%, 93% and 94% |
Only TGP and not the whole plant (decoct) was analysed; no placebo group. Significant differences hint to possible low clinical benefit Only supportive | |
|
Wang YN et al. (2013) beneficial effect of TGP on psoriatic arthritis |
Observation al study |
12 weeks, 3 times daily 600 mg TGP |
19 patients |
Patients with active, psoriatic arthritis, no antiinflammatory medicinal products, DMARD, |
disease activity score (DAS28) Six patients (32%) exhibited >25% decrease of DAS28 |
Low number of patients, no control, only supportive |
|
Type |
Study |
Test Product(s) |
Number of subjects |
Subjects |
Outcomes |
Statistical analysis |
Clinical relevance |
|
immunosuppre ssant 4 weeks before the study; no topical treatment 2 weeks before | |||||||
|
Yang DQ et al. (2012) Efficacy of TGP on alopecia areata |
Randomized controlled trial |
3 month TGP arouD 3 x daily 600 mg TGP 10 mg Vit B2 Glycyrrhizin arouD 3 x daily 50 mg glycyrrhizin 10 mg Vit B2 |
TGP arouD 44 cases Glvcvrrhizin arouD 42 cases |
Patients from 18-65 years with alopecia areata<S3 (the area of hair loss is not greater than 50-75%) |
Four arades of cured 1. Cured: 100% hairs grew again 2. markedly effective: 70% 3. effective: 30% 4. failed In the TGP group cured and markedly effective rate was 36.36%, 50.00% and 68.18% at the end of the first, second and third month of treatment, versus 38.10%, 57.14% and 71.43%. No significant difference between groups |
No placebo control, concomitant use of vitamin B2; Only TGP and not the whole plant (decoct) was analysed | |
|
Zhang HF(2007) efficacy and safety of TGP in non-systemic involved Sjogren syndrome |
retrospectiv e clinical observation |
2 years TGP group hydroxychoroquine (HCQs) group |
nonsystemic involved Sjögren syndrome 27 patients TGP 20 patients |
Increase of saliva secretion TGP group from the 6th month, as in the HCQ group. Decrease of v-globulin TGP group from the 6th month in the HCQ group from the 3th month. |
Only TGP and not the whole plant (decoct) was analysed |
|
Type |
Study |
Test Product(s) |
Number of subjects |
Subjects |
Outcomes |
Statistical analysis |
Clinical relevance |
|
hydroxycho roquine (HCQs) | |||||||
|
Zhang HF, Xiao WG, Hou P (2011) efficacy and adverse reaction of TGP in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus |
retrospectiv e clinical observation |
Duration: More than 5 years 1. TGP1 group: 5 years or more years. 2. TGP2 group: one to 5 years 3. Control group All groups: Cyclophosphamide, prednisone |
TGP1: 29 cases TGP2:47 cases Control group: 20 cases |
patients with systemic lupus erythematosus |
average daily dose of prednisone:TG1<TG2<control total CTX dose: TG1<TG2<control SLE disease activity index: TG1<TG2 No adverse reaction correlated to TGP |
Only TGP and not the whole plant (decoct) was analysed |
4.3. Clinical studies in special populations (e.g. elderly and children)
4.4. Overall conclusions on clinical pharmacology and efficacy
Clinical pharmacological data of peony root decoction/preparations are not available. The published studies were often conducted with total glycosides of peony (TGP, which contains app. 90% paeoniflorin). No placebo controlled studies were available. The prospective controlled clinical studies were often conducted with a low number of patients and comedication was used.
In summary the clinical data do not fulfil the requirements of a well-established medicinal use with recognised efficacy and are not eligible for a marketing authorisation. The efficacy of the herbal preparation(s)/medicinal product is not plausible on the basis of long-standing use.
5. Clinical Safety/Pharmacovigilance
5.1. Overview of toxicological/safety data from clinical trials in humans
Chen Z et al. (2013) analysed in a 24-week, open label, randomized clinical trial the efficacy of total glucosides of peony (TGP) and the protective effect on hepatotoxicity in the combination treatment with methotrexate and leflunomide in 204 patients with active rheumatoid arthritis. The incidence of gastrointestinal tract disturbances, mostly diarrhoea, were higher in the TGP group (TGP plus methotrexate plus leflunomide ) than in the control group methotrexate ( plus leflunomide ), (12.4% vs 1.1%, p=0.002). The authors concluded, although most of these events were mild and self-resolved in 1 to 2 weeks, more attention is needed in clinical praxis.
He and Dai (2011) reported in a review article the first prospective double blind trial of TGP was conducted 1993 in 450 patients with rheumatoid arthritis. They were randomized to receive TGP 1.8 g/day or methotrexate (10 mg/week) for 12 weeks. Therapeutic response was achieved in 71.7 of TGP-treated patients and 81.7 of methotrexate. The adverse events occurred in 13.3% patients and most of them were gastrointestinal tract disturbances, mostly mild diarrhoea. Most of them were selfresolved in 1 to 2 weeks.
Yang DQ et al. (2012) conducted a randomized controlled trial comparing total glucosides of peony capsule and compound glycyrrhizin tablet for alopecia areata 3 month long. A total of 86 outpatients were randomized into two groups. The TGP group of 44 patients received10 mg Vitamin B2 and three times 600 mg TGP daily. The control group received 3 times daily 50 mg glycyrrhizin. In the TGP group occurred 12 adverse reactions: 2x abdominal pain, 6 x loose stool and 4x increase of stool frequency. In the glycyrrhizin group occurred 14 adverse reactions: 2x hypokalemia, 3x increased blood pressure, 5x edema, 2x increased weight, 1x decrease in muscle strength.
5.2. Patient exposure
5.3. Adverse events, serious adverse events and deaths
Timmermans et al. (2009) reported a case of contact dermatitis due to peony in a 56-old nursery man presented a 1 year history of facial eczema. A positive patch test reaction was interpreted as allergic and not as irritant reaction as patch tests with the extracts in 20 controls were negative.
Ward (2005) reported in "The Essential Guide to Clinical Safety" that a statement, bai shao or chi shao were found to be hepatotoxic, was based on one reference that had been incorrectly interpreted and no further evidence supported this. The Traditional Remedies Surveillance Team has repeated stated that no single ingredient has been implicated in the cases of hepatic reactions to herbs. There is still a lack of incidence data to fully define this problem, which is not unique to Chinese herbal medicine.
Ahmad et al. (2012) reported from the traditional TCM use adverse reactions as blistering of mouth and throat, diarrhoea, dizziness, fainting, gastroenteritis, haematuria, nausea, salivation, stomach pain, vomiting and/or possible death were known.
5.4. Laboratory findings
5.5. Safety in special populations and situations
5.5.1. Use in children and adolescents
5.5.2. Contraindications
5.5.3. Special warnings and precautions for use
5.5.4. Drug interactions and other forms of interaction
According to Landmark (2008) antiepileptic medicinal products have a high propensity to interact with concomitant medications. The administration of phenytoin in combination with Paeoniae Radix increased phenytoin Tmax 3-fold in rat model and this was attributed to a delay of phenytoin absorption. In a clinical experimental study with valproate no changes in biochemistry analyses were observed.
Chen LC et al. (2000) evaluated clinical interactions between the antiepileptic substance valproic acid and Paeoniae Radix, used as adjunct in some epileptic patients. The pharmacokinetics of VPA were investigated in a randomized, open-label, two-way crossover study. Six healthy volunteers received the following treatments in a crossover design:
(i) 1-2 g extract powder of Paeoniae Radix once daily for 7 days and one 200 mg VPA on day 7 or
(ii) One 200 mg VPA tablet alone on day 7.
The mean maximum plasma concentration of VPA was attained at within 6 h after oral administration VPA alone and 3-4 h after oral administration in combination with PR. The plasma level of VPA declined with a half-life of 11.71 and 11.91 h respectively. No statistically significant difference was obtained in the pharmacokinetic parameters Tmax Cmax, AUC, ti/2, MRT, CL/F and Vd/F and the protein binding rates of VPA. No concomitant treatment during 7 days was analysed, as VPA was given only one tablet on day 7.
In the Alternative medicine Review (2001) it was assumed, peony may not be combined with antibiotics. Damage to the gut flora by antibiotics might interfere with the process for cleaving the aglycons of peony and theoretically decreasing peony's efficacy.
5.5.5. Fertility, pregnancy and lactation
Zhang and Dai (2012) reports, that traditional use of peony root in TCM indicated that Radix Paeoniae may have abortifacient activity, so the use should be contraindicated in pregnancy for safety reasons.
5.5.6. Overdose
5.5.7. Effects on ability to drive or operate machinery or impairment of mental ability
5.5.8. Safety in other special situations
No data available.
5.6. Overall conclusions on clinical safety
Available data are not sufficient to establish a European Union monograph.
6. Overall conclusions (benefit-risk assessment)
No clinical studies support the well-established use of peony root in any (western medicine) indication.
The requirements for TU (self-medication character, specified strength/posology, appropriate route of administration, period of traditional use, plausibility and safety) are not met. No constituent with known therapeutic activity or active marker can be recognised by the HMPC.
A public statement on Paeonia lactiflora Pallas, radix (Paeoniae radix alba) is suggested. In conclusion, the following requirements for the establishment of a European Union herbal monograph on traditional or well-established herbal medicinal products containing Paeonia lactiflora Pallas, radix are not fulfilled:
- the requirement laid down in Article 10a of Directive 2001/83/EC that the active substance has a recognised efficacy and an acceptable level of safety and that the period of well-established medicinal use has elapsed
- the requirement laid down in Article 16a(1)(b) of Directive 2001/83/EC that the herbal substance or herbal preparation is "exclusively for administration in accordance with a specified strength and posology"
- the requirement laid down in Article 16a(1)(d) of Directive 2001/83/EC that "the period of traditional use as laid down on Article 16c(1)(c) has elapsed"
- the requirement laid down in Article 16a(1)(e) of Directive 2001/83/EC that "the data on the traditional use of the medicinal product are sufficient; in particular the product proves not to be harmful in the specified conditions of use and the pharmacological effects or efficacy of the medicinal product are plausible on the basis of long-standing use and experience"
The HMPC acknowledges the existence of numerous publications on Paeoniae radix or constituents; however, often an appropriate description of herbal substance or herbal preparations used are missing. Available data are not sufficient to establish a European Union monograph.
Annex
List of references
Page 42/42
Assessment report on Paeonia lactiflora Pallas, radix (Paeoniae radix alba)
EMA/HMPC/762954/2015